-
Some Corinthians have a false view of freedom
("everything is permissible") and of the body ("God will destroy
it"). They argued that going to prostitutes is permissible because they,
being people of spirit, will not be affected by behaviour of the
body.
-
6:12-14 Paul argues against their
false presumption.
-
6:15-20 Paul forbids prostitution;
the theological basis is that such sin is against their bodies.
6:12
"Everything is permissible for me" is a Corinthian
slogan. Paul cites it again in 10:23. For Paul, "everything is permissible"
has to do with the non-essentials: food, drink, days, circumcision, not
with ethical or moral matters.
Corinthians use the term "right to determine"
or "authority" (Greek exousia) [similar to 8:9 where Paul speaks
of "this exousia of yours" of going to the pagan temples].
Two criteria in exercising Christian liberty:
-
Is it "beneficial" to me and to others? (parallel
with "constructive" or "build up" in 10:23)
-
Will I be "mastered" by it ("anything" or
anybody)?
6:13-14
First, the Corinthians' slogan consisted of two
parts:
(a) Food for the stomach and
the stomach for food "and" (translated as "but" is incorrect)
(b) God will destroy both the
one (stomach) and the other (food).
Here, Paul is in essential agreement. Both food and
the stomach belong to the present age, and God will do away with them both
in the end. However, the Corinthians' application derived from this slogan
is incorrect:
(a) They thought that since
food is for the stomach and the stomach for food, and since all bodily
appetites are pretty much alike, that leads to the conclusion that the
body is for sex and sex for the body.
(b) They thought that food
and the body are both temporal and God will destroy them both in the end,
what happens to the body does not matter.
Paul corrects them on both counts starting with the
word "but" (i.e., their derivation is wrong):
(a) The body is not for sexual
immorality, but for the Lord "and"
(b) The body is not destined
for destruction but for resurrection, the proof of which is Christ's resurrection.
Paul counters their slogan with his own parallel
theological construct: "The body is for the Lord, and the Lord for the
body." The meaning of "the Lord is for the body" is not clear but may mean
the Lord has given himself for the redemption of the body.
6:15-17
The argument against prostitution is in two parts.
(a) The bodies of believers
are "members" of the "body" of Christ (v.15a) because each individual
believer is joined to ["united with"] Christ and becomes one S/spirit
with him (v.17).
(b) On the basis of Gen 2:24
(v.16b), in sexual intercourse two bodies become one. With prostitution,
the body of the believer is joined to ["united with"] the prostitute
(v.16a) and becomes a "member" of her body (v.15b).
Since a believer cannot be the member of the body
of the prostitute and the member of the body of Christ, prostitution precludes
a person from being in the body of Christ.
6:18-20
3 reasons why sexual immorality is wrong:
(a) It is a sin against one's
own body (v.18).
(b) The body is the present
habitation of God's Spirit (v.19) and should be kept holy.
(c) The body is God's rightful
possession because it is redeemed with a great price in the death of Christ
(v.20).